Barefoot Cay: About 30 minutes from busy West End are these ocean-view lofts ($215) and beach villas. From the dock it's an easy swim (or kayak) to the world-famous reef. We wore swimsuits to every dinner — the staff is like family. Palmetto Bay Plantation: This palapa is practically on the reef. The villas ($225) sit among coconut trees on a mile-long beach and are almost as serene as the underwater world. There's even a tropical-bird preserve on the property. Anthony's Key: Roatan is to diving what Sicily is to pasta. Everyone who's visiting the island has come to try it. Anthony's Key caters to that singular focus. The room rate ($168) includes three dives and three meals a day. The wallet stays in the safe. | S.Jackson
ByRobert StephensJan. 16, 2015
Most visitors come to Roatan via cruise ship, so there's little demand for cars and rooms (notice the quiet airport). Even then, it's mostly divers looking for a place to hang wetsuits. The result: high-end resorts with low-end rates.