United States Green Turtle Cay, Bahamas 2008 Sign in town of New Plymouth By Islands Staff Dec. 14, 2009 ISLANDS editor Chris Tauber stayed on Green Turtle Cay in the Bahamas with his family. Sign at Green Turtle Club One of many undiscovered beaches here. The resort seen from the dock. The family-friendly beach next to the resort's patio restaurant. Walking through the resort. One of the new island homes on the market. Home of the famous Goombay Smash. House drink at the Green Turtle Club: pineapple juice, orange juice and rum. Lunch sandwich featuring fresh local lobster. Restaurant at the Bluff House resort. Historic — and only — town on Green Turtle Cay. Walk-up window for ice cream next to McIntosh restaurant in town of New Plymouth. Crisp blue water on Green Turtle's oceanfront. Dive shop next door to Green Turtle Club, featuring trips, gear rental and bikes. Four-wheel, hard-core golf carts, the best way to explore the island and its rocky back roads.