Indiana's 'Outdoor Recreation Destination' Is An Underrated County Lake With Unique Attractions

Indiana is a treasure trove of wonders, blending artificial marvels, like Indianapolis' scenic Massachusetts Avenue, with serene small towns offering year-round beauty and covered bridge trails. The Hoosier State is equally beloved for its lush farmlands and picturesque natural landscapes. One of Indiana's most charming small towns is Brookville. Nestled in the Whitewater River Valley near the Ohio border, this underrated gem offers breathtaking lake views and vibrant local culture in Franklin County, which lives up to its reputation as an "outdoor recreation destination."

Along the Whitewater Canal Byway (Indiana's best scenic drive), Brookville's allure lies in its blend of nature and welcoming ambiance. It is surrounded by the Whitewater River and Brookville Lake, part of Whitewater Memorial State Park. After a day spent exploring the waterfront or engaging in activities such as fishing and boating, visitors can retreat to the quaint downtown area. With its eclectic mix of local shops, cafés, and eateries, Brookville offers an inviting atmosphere that feels like a home away from home. It's a perfect escape from the fast pace of city life, allowing visitors to reconnect with nature and experience small-town hospitality.

The town's proximity to the Whitewater River and Brookville Lake, an artificial reservoir, is its defining feature. Spanning 5,260 acres, Brookville Lake State Park is a haven for outdoor enthusiasts. It boasts more than 25 miles of hiking trails, two sandy beaches, and amenities for camping, including restrooms, electrical hookups, and a store. Families can enjoy swimming, hiking, and horseback riding at Whitewater Memorial State Park. The reservoir is also incredibly significant from a geological and historical point of view, as it's home to prehistoric Native American mounds and 450-million-year-old Ordovician fossils. 

Fishing enthusiasts will appreciate the lake's abundance of walleye, catfish, smallmouth bass, largemouth bass, and crappie. Birdwatchers can spot species like wood thrush, Kentucky warbler, prairie warbler, osprey, and bald eagles. The area's ecological diversity makes it an essential habitat for flora and fauna to flourish.

For a relaxing end to the day, visit Ainsley's Cafe and Harbor Bar, located near the marina. Open seasonally from April to October, this nautical-themed eatery offers American classics like sandwiches and pizza with stunning lakeside views. It's an ideal spot to watch the sunset on the water while enjoying a peaceful meal.

Beyond its outdoor appeal, Brookville's downtown area captures the essence of small-town America. Thanks to ongoing preservation efforts by the local non-profit organization Brookville Mainstreet, the town is a thriving destination for visitors. Its walkable streets are lined with boutique shops, artisan craft stores, and antique retailers such as La-Di-Da Boutique and Unique Design, Salt Creek Antiques and Gift Shop, and Schwestern Gallery of Arts.

Brookville's vibrant dining scene includes local favorites like Dairy Cottage and the family-owned Coffee on Main. In 2024, the town introduced a Designated Outdoor Refreshment Area (DORA), allowing visitors of legal drinking age to enjoy alcoholic beverages while strolling through specified areas. Participating establishments include Third Place, Pioneer Restaurant and Lounge, and Knights of Columbus, among others. 

Despite its small population of 2,650 (as of 2024), Brookville offers a well-rounded experience for those seeking abundant outdoor adventure, lakeside relaxation, or downtown exploration. Whether you're fishing on the lake, hiking the trails, or enjoying the charm of Main Street, Brookville is a hidden gem in the heart of Indiana.